I raided (with permission) my mom’s button stash in my sewing room for buttons for PB’s second sporty cardigan.
I came out with two nice grey/black neutral options. My mom suggested putting them in the button holes to really get a feel for what they would look like. She’s pretty smart you know. The ones on the left have a nice two toned look that I dig. But the ones on the right have a little bit of smoothness and sheen. I’m letting myself sleep on it but I’m kinda leaning towards the ones on the left.
What do you think?
My Tangled Yarn Knitting Adventures 
I like the ones on the right but I couldn’t tell you why.
Same as hedgehog.
I second your current preference 🙂 not too keen on the fullness in the centre of the right ones
I also like the ones on the right! But its PB’s sweater, so you do what’s right for you 🙂
I actually like the ones with the sheen:)
I like the ones on the right.
That appears to be the consensus!
I like the left side
I would be tempted to save the ones on the right for a project that will have a longer life than the cardigan for PB. The ones on the left look good, but if you used the ones on the right for an adult garment you’d get to enjoy their lovely sheen for years, rather than months.
I prefer the left ones for this project. The ones on the right are nice, but maybe will work better on a different project still to be knitted. 🙂
Pingback: FO Friday: PB’s Sporty Cardigan #2 | My Tangled Yarn Knitting Adventures
I like the ones on the right but at the rate you are going with baby sweaters you will be able to use both sets
I like the right!
Very pretty options! I like the ones on the left
The ones with the sheen